Nearly everyone believes that persons have a special moral status. It is based on the interest view which ascribes moral standing to beings with interests, and connects the possession of interests with the capacity for conscious awareness or sentience. June 2017 volume 19 number 1 health and human rights journal 29 theorizing time in abortion law and human rights joanna n. On the moral and legal status of abortion 3 in order to discuss the moral and legal aspect of abortion, it is important to understand both sides of the argument. Taking the life of another person, barring extreme circumstances, is a grievous. When analyzing the abortion phenomenon, one might argue that considering the fetus status is not the issue of primary importance. The assumption she attacks is particularly invidious, for it amounts to the decision that it is appropriate, in deciding. Arguments for and against abortion in terms of teleological and deontological theories. Prochoice emphasizes the right of women to decide whether to terminate a pregnancy.
Above all, there is no consensus on when a human life also becomes a human person. Warren defends an extremely permissive view on abortion, according to which abortion is morally permissible at any stage of the pregnancy and under any circumstances. Life before birth provides a coherent framework for addressing bioethical issues in which the moral status of embryos and fetuses is relevant. Highly restrictive laws do not eliminate the practice of abortion, but make. Pdf the legal regulation of abortion by gestational age, or length of.
Unfortunately, there is no consensus on the definitions of the terms human life, pregnancy, or human personhood. For purposes of our discussion we will be defining abortion as follows. Chapter 20 on the moral and legal status of abortion. Mary warren, on the moral and legal status of abortion, 1973. The moral implication of abortion artsbeat concepts. The other extreme position towards abortion and moral status of the fetus is liberal.
I will show that the fetus is not a person, and hence not worthy of full moral rights. Lecture 6 notes warren and singer introduction to philosophy. Oxford university press usa publishes scholarly works in all academic disciplines, bibles, music, childrens books, business books, dictionaries, reference books, journals, text books and more. The fundamental problem with respect to justifying abortion is the moral status of the fetus. This is one of the key factor involved in the morality of abortion. Start studying mary anne warren, on the moral and legal status of abortion. Summary of mary anne warrens on the moral and legal status.
Human rights law does not accept the claim that moral ends justify all means of restriction. Third, abortion ethics involves a dialectical interplay between rights and responsibilities, and between social, cultural, and particular contexts, and is best understood in terms of moral. The proponents of the prolife based their reasoning on the moral grounds of either religious or. Legal abortion is safer and easier the earlier it is done. If fetuses have the same moral rights as adults, then abortion is morally. Yet struggles over time in abortion law, and its competing. On the moral and legal status of abortion pdf on the moral and legal status of. In some cases, this map may not accurately depict the content of this article. The legal status of the fetus sara fovargue, jose miola. The sides involved in the debate are the selfdescribed prochoice and prolife movements.
Warren on the moral and legal status of abortion introduction paper has three basic parts criticism of thomson argument against a fetuss right to life based on being a potential person discussion of how her account relates to infanticide argument against thomson it is only in the case of pregnancy due. Law, metaphysics, and moral neutrality ethics at the edge. Jan 30, 2014 on the moral and legal status of abortion mary anne warrens argument that because women are persons and fetuses are not, womens rights override whatever right to life a fetus may possess because of the characteristics of personhood and moral community that a fetus does not yet have warren 164 is shown through the following argument. The morality of abortion and its implication with infanticide. Wade what follows is an outline of mary anne warrens 1973 piece, on the moral and legal status of abortion.
Mary anne warren begins her discussion of abortion by disagreeing with judith thomson. No amount of moral preaching, ethical discussions, or legal wrangling will change that reality. On the moral and legal status of abortion 1423 words. On the moral and legal status of abortion we will be concerned with both the moral status of abortion, which for our purposes we may define as the act which a woman performs in voluntarily terminating, or allowing another person to terminate, her pregnancy, and the legal status which is appropriate for this act. Abortion moral status of the fetus only part of justification of abortion equally important, womens rights to bodily self determination women are not fetal containers no woman should be forced to continue a pregnancy if she is not ready to be a mother contraception preferable to abortion, but abortion still necessary. In this paper, i will examine and critique mary anne warrens on the moral and legal status of abortion, where she examines the moral humanity of the fetus and its right to life. Mary anne warren, on the moral and legal status of abortion. Maternal mortality includes abortion related deaths.
I would like to turn my attention now to another popular essay written by mary anne warren called on the moral and legal status of abortion. Part ii reprinted, with postscript, in the problem of abortion. When engaging in culturally and ethically controversial topics like abortion, i have found that most people latch onto a specific idea and use it to counter every argument offered against their view. The article that follows international law and the right to abortion examines the basis for claiming that a right to abortion exists in international law and concludes that the claim is without legal foundation, and states may therefore legislate in defense of prenatal life. On the moral and legal status of abortion essay 626 words. Mary anne warren describes how abortion should be kept legal without any restrictions on it. John noonan objects to the example of the unconscious violinist of thomsons model and offers a more realistic example. The proponents of the prolife based their reasoning on the moral grounds of either religious or humanistic approach. Abortion and infanticide are not morally seriously wrong. In order to define whether the fetus has any moral status, and hence, moral value and rights, liberals take into consideration whether it complies with demands of personhood, such as. A critique of mary anne warrens on the moral and legal. Natural or non induced abortions are commonly known as miscarriages. Warren considers the following anti abortion argument.
Theorizing time in abortion law and human rights ncbi. Some of these laws are referred to as targeted regulation of abortion providers trap, because they place absurd requirements and regulations on physicians and clinics that facilitate. Moral and legal status of abortion 45 is wrong except perhaps when necessary to save the womans life, and that it ought to be prohibited. By definition, then, maternal mortality must be equal than or greater to abortion mortality. It is a classic of the literature and is still reprinted in college textbooks. Third, abortion ethics involves a dialectical interplay between rights and responsibilities, and between social, cultural, and particular contexts, and is best understood in terms of moral praxis. Essentially, the fetus has a moral value that is greater than zero, but less than a person, and it. In countries where abortion is illegal unless it is to save a girls or a womans life, many risk permanent injury and death through unsafe abortion practices. Dr sara fovargue is a senior lecturer in law at lancaster university, specializing in healthcare law and ethics, and is also a member of the editorial committee of clinical ethics. A moral and legal case against abortion choice and a previous article in this journal, defending abortion philosophically, from which the main moral arguments of that book were earlier presented, francis beckwith argues that fetuses1 are prima facie wrong to kill.
Legal status of abortion the question of the legal status of abortion should be resolved in the legislature because the legislature is a representative of the people. It has also been generally as sumed that unless the question about the status of the fetus is an swered, the moral status of abortion cannot possibly be determined. Fetal development and the right to life two problems arise in the application of these suggestions for the definition of the moral community to the determination of the precise moral status of a human fetus. But just because it is legal now, listen carefully it doesnt mean it is moral. The objection against abortion is based on the notion of transcendent human rights. The abortion debate is the ongoing controversy surrounding the moral, legal, and religious status of induced abortion. Abortion mortality is a subset of maternal mortality. Legal criticisms of the roe decision address many points, among them are several suggesting that it is an overreach of judicial powers, or that it was not properly based on the constitution, or that it is an example of judicial activism and that it should be overturned so that abortion law can be decided by legislatures.
Health and human rights journal theorizing time in abortion. We concluded that we simply didnt know whether or not the fetus is a person. On the moral and legal status of abortion douglas ficek. He argues that abortion is almost never morally permissible beyond rare cases where, unless the. If it would be morally permissible to unplug yourself in the violinist case, then typical abortions are morally. Nevertheless, it became clear that illegal abortions continued to take place in large numbers even where abortions. Warrens argument for a pregnant womans moral right to an abortion a fetus is not a person. On the moral and legal status of abortion mary anne warren from biomedical ethics. Pdf arguments for and against abortion in terms of. The moral status of the fetus in abortion read a free. One has moral status if he or his interests matter for his own sake. I will agree that since abortion is legal a woman receives a legal right to have an abortion. The first page of the pdf of this article appears below. That question is key to any discussion or debate over abortion access.
If fetuses have the same moral rights as adults, then abortion is morally wrong. There is a strong connection between views on whether abortion should be legal and views on the morality of having an abortion. A non human moral agent dog can treat a human adult with no relationship as creature without moral status. Abortion marry anne warren on the moral and legal status of abortion, and utilitarianism. It would be morally permissible to unplug yourself in the violinist case. Wadehave brought about significant advances for the lives and health of women. So my minor disagreement with warren is that talk of moral rights only. Philosophers and the issue of abortion page 3 of 6 72700 the conservative position contends that from conception the fetus has full moral status. The united states supreme court membership in 1973 at the time of roe v. Georgette forney, president, anglicans for life cofounder of the national silent no more awareness campaign many people look at abortion from a political position but as a woman who has personally experienced one, i look at this issue from a different perspective. Jul 01, 2017 by contrast, in the following essay part iii of arcs discussion on the moral questions surrounding abortion i argue that, not only can one believe abortion is immoral and should be legal, but that this is the most defensible position. Aug 14, 20 i recently gave an indepth critique of one of the most important articles ever written on the abortion issue.
Making abortion illegal does not stop girls and women from seeking an abortion. For instance, feminists refer to it as to a social problem rather than a moral dilemma as they concentrate on outer influences, factors and conditions that lead to it steinbock 40. So a pregnant woman has a moral right to an abortion. Summary of mary anne warrens on the moral and legal status of abortion. On the moral and legal status of abortion au coeur. Part ii reprinted, with postscript, in the problem of abortion, 1984, joel feinberg, ed. What we found, of course, was that arguments against the personhood status of. It is not to be confused with what we will call the genetic sense. But unfortunately, once we allow the assumption that a fetus has full moral rights, we cannot avoid taking this absurd suggestion seriously. A fetus, therefore, does not have full moral rights.
The reality of abortion reflections of my journey by mrs. If you need further advice or help you can contact one of the organisations on page 16. Antiabortion movements, also referred to as prolife movements, were led by a combination of groups opposed to abortion on moral grounds, and by medical professionals who were concerned about the danger presented by the procedure and the regular involvement of nonmedical personnel in performing abortions. Definitions of abortion mortality produced by the population research institute note. It offers its own set of evaluation criteria when dealing with the issue. On the moral and legal status of abortion mary anne warren.
Abortion is the process by which an embryo or fetus is removed from the uterus, resulting in the termination of a pregnancy. On the moral and legal status of abortion 1 on the moral. On the moral and legal status of abortion 1423 words bartleby. The commentary on peter singers views of infanticide does not portray mr. Summary of mary anne warrens on the moral and legal. We shall argue that the choice of abortion is objectively immoral. Moral status, rights, and abortion flashcards quizlet. The sides involved in the debate are the selfdescribed prochoice movement who emphasizing the right of women to decide whether to terminate a pregnancy.
The legal regulation of abortion by gestational age, or length of pregnancy. Most opponents of legal abortion 80% say having an abortion is morally wrong. On the moral and legal status of abortion continued capacity to communicate selfawareness moral agency fetus possesses none of these six. When a woman is pregnant, how should we understand the. Abortion was a leading cause of maternal mortality in preroe america, and it remains so today in many developing countries in which abortion is illegal. Abortion deliberate removal or deliberate action to cause the expulsion of a fetus from the womb of a human female, at the request of or through the agency of the mother, so as in fact to result in the death of the fetus. The debate hinges on the moral status of the fetus. What follows is an outline of mary anne warrens 1973 piece, on the moral and legal status of abortion. Most supporters of legal abortion, on the other hand, say abortion is morally acceptable 18% or that it is not a moral issue 42%. Three decades of legal abortion thirty years of legal abortion since roe v.
Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Fetuses are neither persons nor members of the moral community women are undeniable persons and members of the moral community laws that deny women the right to obtain abortion, or that make safe abortion difficult to obtain are unjustifiable violation of the basic moral and constitutional rights. Health and human rights journal theorizing time in. On the moral and legal status of abortion stephen hicks. Whereas thomson stated that, even if the fetus has a full right to life, abortion is.
Definitions of abortion mortality population research institute. Thats why, in the uk, where abortion is legal, most people want it to stay that way. Wadsworth we will be concerned with both the moral statu1 s of abortion, which for our purposes we may define as the act. The debate on abortion is a controversial issue in moral philosophy, legal status of induced abortion and the well being of the society. Pdf theorizing time in abortion law and human rights. There is a difference between being legal and being moral. Abortion kills an innocent human being who is distinct from his mother. On the moral and legal status of abortion mary anne warrens argument that because women are persons and fetuses are not, womens rights override whatever right to life a fetus may possess because of the characteristics of personhood and moral community that a fetus does not yet have warren 164 is shown through the following argument. Since the legislature is a representative of the people it can establish statutes, which are favorable to the entire society as opposed to the judicial system, which overlooks the.
329 1492 374 118 497 1650 504 636 1004 139 14 305 125 1556 1169 187 698 966 422 168 1198 750 1161 1588 1019 896 941 803 704 256 1062 963 1011 1191 959 208 774 861 1322 615 664 902 694